How to Pick a High Value Cheese

November 21, 2026

3 min read

Great cheese is simple: real milk, a little time, and a block you grate yourself.

Here’s how to pick cheese that tastes better, melts better and sits well with you.

1. Choose real cheese

Look for a short ingredient list: milk, cultures, salt and enzymes. That’s real cheese.

Real cheese is made from just those few things, sometimes with annatto for color. A short list means you’re getting cheese and nothing else.

American singles and anything labeled “cheese product” are processed: real cheese melted down with emulsifying salts and extra milk proteins so it melts perfectly smooth. A block of real cheese costs about the same and gives you more cheese and more flavor.

2. Aged cheese is easy to digest

The longer a cheese ages, the less milk sugar is left, so aged cheeses are often easy for people sensitive to lactose.

Most of the milk sugar (lactose) drains away with the whey when cheese is made. As cheese ages, good bacteria turn what’s left into lactic acid. A Parmesan aged 12 months has about 0.1 gram of lactose per 100 grams, which is basically none.

Aged cheddar, Gruyère and Parmigiano-Reggiano are all naturally low in lactose. You also get more flavor and more protein in every bite, because aged cheese holds less water.

3. Raw-milk cheese: traditional flavor

Raw-milk cheeses like Le Gruyère AOP have a fuller, deeper flavor, and in the US they’re aged at least 60 days, so they’re naturally low in lactose too.

Raw-milk cheese is made from milk that isn’t pasteurized, the way cheese has been made for centuries. Le Gruyère AOP, for example, is made in Switzerland from the raw milk of cows fed grass and hay, with no additives, and aged at least 5 months.

The aging is what makes these cheeses gentle on digestion, and it’s also where their flavor comes from. If aged cheese works for you, raw-milk cheese is a delicious place to explore.

4. Grate your own

A block you grate at home melts smoother and silkier than a bag of pre-shredded cheese.

Pre-shredded cheese is coated with a little potato starch or cellulose so the shreds don’t stick together in the bag. It’s safe and handy, but a freshly grated block melts into that smooth, gooey pull you want. Grating takes about 30 seconds.

Pre-sliced cheese is usually the same as the block, just cut for you.

5. Best cheeses for melting and flavor

Young cheeses melt, aged cheeses bring the flavor, and mixing the two gives you both.

  • Melters: Gruyère, Monterey Jack, Fontina, mozzarella.
  • Flavor: aged cheddar, smoked gouda, pepper jack.
  • Crispy crust: Parmigiano-Reggiano, grated onto buttered bread. It crisps into a golden, cheesy shell.

For a grilled cheese, try Gruyère and aged cheddar inside with a Parmesan crust outside.

6. Names worth looking for

Look for “Le Gruyère AOP” and “Parmigiano-Reggiano” on the label for the traditional versions.

In the US, “gruyere” and “parmesan” are general names, so they can be made anywhere and any way. The protected names tell you you’re getting the real thing.

  • Le Gruyère AOP: made in Switzerland from raw milk, aged at least 5 months.
  • Parmigiano-Reggiano: made in a specific region of Italy from only milk, salt and rennet, aged at least 12 months. Look for the name stamped on the rind.

Sources: Interprofession du Gruyère v. U.S. Dairy Export Council (4th Cir. 2023) · Le Gruyère AOP characteristics · Parmigiano Reggiano Consortium FAQ · Effect of raw milk on lactose intolerance (Annals of Family Medicine, 2014) · PBS SoCal on pre-shredded cheese · The Takeout on Parmesan lactose

Free download

Get the HV Recipe Scorecard.

Rate your own dishes the way I do. Free printable PDF.

Support the project

Feeling generous?

Fuel the kitchen

Thank you.

Zelle tthren9@gmail.com

Tips support High Value Cooking as a small business and aren't tax-deductible.